When child abuse comes to the church

Watch the video of the sermon below. Or read the text summary that follows.

This message is best watched – it has quite a lot of content. But if you prefer, here are my notes that guided the sermon:

When child abuse comes to the church

  • WhatsApp message from a parishioner on Friday: “Adrian. What’s happening in our Anglican Church?”
  • Church as sanctuary and moral authority
  • But when child abuse comes to the church…
  • Catholic, Hillsong, Conservative Baptists, etc
  • And now Anglican Communion
  • Personal for me:
    • I was sexually exploited by a leader in teens
    • Church could not take a clear stand
    • Silenced, shamed, theology
    • Now I’m a Rector – responsible to safeguard a parish

Context of today’s message

  • Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin, resigned on Tue
  • Archbishop of CofE and of the Anglican communion
  • Our Archbishop, Thabo Makgoba, has been called by some to resign
  • He responded on Wed & Friday, more this week
  • All in a time of splintering around sexuality & gender
  • John Smyth – evangelical lay person
  • Physical beating of children in UK, Zim & SA from 1970s
  • Lived in SA from 2005? to 2018, attended ACSA
  • Physical and sexual abuse rampant churches
  • Children, women, young men
  • This has both theological and pastoral implications

Theologies that may enable abuse in the church

  • Adult authority over children
  • Proverbs 13:24, “Whoever spares the rod hates their children, but the one who loves their children is careful to discipline them”
  • Theologies of salvation
  • God’s requirement of blood for forgiveness
  • Glorification of Jesus violent death – blood blood
  • Predominance of masculine values
  • power, control, hierarchy, authority, sexism
  • Leaders answer to God only, not men
  • Free to do as they please – little oversight
  • Theologies of forgiveness
  • RC confession, absolution, wiped clean, as if
  • Seal of the confessional
  • Conspiracy – cover-up each other
  • Theologies of sanctification
  • Belief in capacity for personal reform
  • Second chances
  • Belief in the basic goodness of everyone (despite Paul’s even our best like dirty rags)

Pastoral implications: What should we do?

  • Pastoral implications 1: Open eyes
  • Church easy pickings
  • Adults: clever, deceptive, duplicit, psychop
  • Children: model, ignorance, curiosity, empathy
  • Victims: threatened, coerced, made complicit > shame & fear>silence
  • Perps: hard to believe they’d do that
  • Fear: false accusations can destroy one
  • Pastoral implications 2: Theological stance
  • Theology of love is central
  • God’s love for every person – better or worse
  • God’s image of a united humanity under Christ
  • Church should be a sanctuary, safe community
  • A place for redemption, healing, transformation
  • ACSA Code of Pastoral Standards
  • Safe & Inclusive Church: Disclosure by all leaders
  • Separate, independent – they investigate
  • Google: Safe Church Guide
  • Need to be more diligent about this – Jan annually
  • Pastoral implications 3: Actions
  • We are all broken and fall short of God’s glory
  • We are all capable of harming self and others
  • There is potential for redemption & forgiveness
  • Potential for transformation & wholeness
  • But we are all on a journey
  • Talk with your children about safety, touching
  • Listen to your children when they raise issues
  • Don’t be naïve (mini-perps)
  • Keep your eyes and ears open
  • Listen to your intuition (Holy Spirit’s whisper)
  • Intervene if immediate & safe
  • Speak to me, wardens, councillors
  • If me, speak to wardens or archdeacon or bishop
  • Contact Safe Church – email, form
  • Pastoral implications 4: Prayer
  • Let us pray for the church, leaders & children
  • Pray for wholeness and holiness for us all
  • Pray for victims – healing and restoration
  • Pray for perpetrators – HS conscience and empathy
  • Pray for leaders – standards, conviction
  • Pray for safeguarding members – discernment